ConvertKit vs. Pico: Which One is Better for Your Business?

Jessica Li
Chief of Staff

Link-in-bio products are crucial for online creators as they centralize various aspects of their creator business, making it easier to manage and grow. We'll compare ConvertKit and Pico to determine which platform best supports creators in this endeavor.

A Quick Overview of ConvertKit and Pico

What is ConvertKit?

clickup screenshot

ConvertKit is an email-first operating system designed to help creators build and grow their businesses. It offers tools for email marketing, audience segmentation, automation, and selling digital products. Unique features include customizable email creation, visual automations, and a free migration service for users with over 5,000 subscribers on paid plans.

What is Pico?

clickup screenshot

Pico is a marketing tool designed to help businesses, particularly gyms, grow their community and revenue. It offers features like link-in-bio, QR codes, CRM, and monetization options through tips and subscriptions. The platform is user-friendly with easy setup and customization, and it provides various pricing plans to suit different needs.

Comparing ConvertKit and Pico: Features and Pricing

ConvertKit Features

ConvertKit offers several unique features that cater to the needs of creators.

  • Email Editor: Create unique and customizable emails with ease.
  • Visual Automations: Automate customer journeys to save time and enhance engagement.
  • Tags & Segments: Manage your audience with detailed segmentation for personalized content.
  • Sell Products: Directly sell digital products through the platform.
  • Recommendations: Grow your email list through recommendations from other creators, a feature that sets ConvertKit apart from competitors.

Pico Features

Pico offers a range of features designed to help businesses grow their community and revenue.

  • Link-in-Bio and QR Codes: Share links and collect leads effortlessly.
  • Direct Engagement: Reach followers and members directly with blasts and DMs through CRM, SMS, and email.
  • Monetization: Build subscription products and receive payments with daily deposits, including tips and subscriptions.
  • Comprehensive Online and Offline Growth: Grow your business with a website, built-in web forms, and accessories to share links.
  • All-in-One Solution: Eliminate the need for multiple apps; Pico consolidates all essential tools into one platform.

ConvertKit and Pico Similarities

ConvertKit and Pico both excel in helping creators and businesses grow through comprehensive marketing tools. They share several key features that make them valuable for managing and expanding an online presence.

  • Email Marketing: Both platforms offer robust email marketing tools to engage and nurture audiences.
  • Automations: Streamline workflows with automation features available on both ConvertKit and Pico.
  • Audience Segmentation: Tag and segment audiences for personalized content delivery.
  • Lead Generation: Capture leads effectively with landing pages and forms.
  • Subscription Management: Manage subscribers and offer paid newsletters or subscription products.
  • Integrations: Enhance functionality with integrations to other tools and services.

ConvertKit and Pico Differences

While both ConvertKit and Pico offer robust tools for creators, their feature sets cater to different needs. ConvertKit focuses on email marketing and automation, whereas Pico emphasizes direct engagement and monetization.

  • Visual Automations: ConvertKit allows creators to automate customer journeys, a feature not available in Pico.
  • Daily Payouts: Pico offers daily payouts for earnings, which ConvertKit does not provide.
  • Recommendations: ConvertKit has a unique feature where other creators can help grow your email list, something Pico lacks.

ConvertKit and Pico Pricing

ConvertKit offers three pricing plans: the Newsletter Plan at $0/month, the Creator Plan at $25/month, and the Creator Pro Plan at $50/month. Annual billing provides a discount, with the Creator Plan at $290/year and the Creator Pro Plan at $590/year. Both paid plans include a 14-day free trial and a 30-day refund policy.

Pico's pricing includes a Free plan, Lite at $9/month, Essentials at $39/month, Community at $99/month, and Scale at $299/month. All paid plans come with a 14-day free trial. Pico's plans vary in the number of pages and texts allowed, with unlimited emails across all tiers.

Overall, ConvertKit offers more affordable options for creators, especially with its free plan and lower-cost paid plans.

Why Choose One Over the Other?

Why Choose ConvertKit Over Pico

Consumers who prioritize email marketing and need advanced automation features would prefer ConvertKit. This platform is ideal for content creators, entrepreneurs, and digital marketers who want to build and manage their businesses through robust email marketing tools.

Why Choose Pico Over ConvertKit

Consumers who need an all-in-one marketing solution with features like link-in-bio, QR codes, and daily payouts would find Pico more suitable. This platform is perfect for gym owners, small business owners, and community managers who require a comprehensive tool to manage both online and offline engagement.

Considering Beacons vs. ConvertKit and Pico

What is Beacons

clickup screenshot

Beacons is the all-in-one creator platform designed to help you manage and monetize your online presence effortlessly. With millions of users worldwide, Beacons offers unique features like customizable link-in-bio, AI-generated brand outreach, and an income dashboard to streamline your business operations.

Beacons's Pricing

Beacons Pricing Packages

  • Free Plan: $0
  • Creator Pro: $8.33 per month (billed annually) or $10 per month (billed monthly)
  • Store Pro: $25 per month (billed annually) or $30 per month (billed monthly)
  • Business Pro: $75 per month (billed annually) or $90 per month (billed monthly)

Comparing Beacons to ConvertKit and Pico

Choosing Beacons over ConvertKit and Pico offers a comprehensive solution for creators looking to maximize their online presence and revenue.

  • All-in-One Platform: Unlike ConvertKit and Pico, Beacons combines link-in-bio, email marketing, an online store, and more into a single platform.
  • AI Brand Outreach: Beacons leverages AI to help you secure brand deals, a feature not available in ConvertKit or Pico.
  • Income Dashboard: Track your earnings effortlessly with Beacons' income dashboard, providing a clear financial overview.
  • Customizable Media Kit: Create and update media kits automatically, saving time and ensuring consistency.
  • Early Pay: Get paid faster with Beacons' Early Pay feature, which is not offered by ConvertKit or Pico.
  • Audience Manager: Manage and segment your audience with advanced tools, enhancing engagement and growth.
  • Link Shortener and Post Activity: Optimize your links and track post performance seamlessly.
  • Pricing Calculator and W-9 Generator: Simplify financial tasks with built-in tools that streamline your business operations.

Beacons doesn't just match the features of ConvertKit and Pico; it surpasses them by offering a more integrated and efficient solution for creators.

What Are the Customers Saying?

ConvertKit Reviews

Overall, users have given ConvertKit a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars. While many appreciate its ease of use and robust automation tools, some find the pricing steep and the feature set limited.

"Easy to use and great customer service"

Rating: 5.0 out of 5

- Verified User in Arts and Crafts

The user praised ConvertKit for its great pricing, customer service, and good deliverability. They mentioned a learning curve for new users but found the overall experience positive.

"Why I left Convertkit after just 45 days (and ate $750)"

Rating: 1.0 out of 5

- Zak F.

Zak F. highlighted several issues, including the inability to organize images, embed audio, and track metrics for subscriber segments. He also criticized the strict refund policy.

For more reviews, visit Hype Reviews.

Pico Reviews

Overall, users have given ConvertKit a rating of 4.4 out of 5 stars. While many appreciate its ease of use and robust automation tools, some find the pricing steep and the feature set limited.

"Easy to use and great customer service"

Rating: 5.0 out of 5

- Verified User in Arts and Crafts

The user praised ConvertKit for its great pricing, customer service, and good deliverability. They mentioned a learning curve for new users but found the overall experience positive.

"Why I left Convertkit after just 45 days (and ate $750)"

Rating: 1.0 out of 5

- Zak F.

Zak F. highlighted several issues, including the inability to organize images, embed audio, and track metrics for subscriber segments. He also criticized the strict refund policy.

For more reviews, visit Hype Reviews.

Beacons reviews

Overall, users have given Beacons an impressive rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Here are some of the positive reviews from our satisfied customers:

"Incredible app with a bunch of useful creator business tools"

Rating: 5.0 out of 5

- Christopher Wong

"Probably the most outstanding link app w/ tons of features especially for building and connecting community!"

Rating: 5.0 out of 5

- Viva Stylez

Final Decision: ConvertKit, Pico, or Beacons?

All three platforms—ConvertKit, Pico, and Beacons—offer valuable tools for online creators looking to grow their audience and manage their business. However, Beacons stands out as the all-in-one solution that simplifies everything from email marketing to securing brand deals. If you're looking for a comprehensive tool that can handle it all, Beacons is the way to go.

Read these next

Need help?
[email protected]
Get Beacons on Apple StoreGet Beacons on Google Play
Beacons® is a registered trademark of Beacons AI Inc. ©2023